The Geddes Axe

Trades in Whisky and Soda

The USA has a $36 trillion debt and an outsized annual budget deficit which appears to be structural. I say that because a surplus hasn’t been registered since the stockmarket boom of 2000, when capital gains tax revenues surged. 25 years later, and the stockmarket has surged again, yet the tax receipts haven’t had quite the same impact as they did last time, as the deficit has become too big. The US deficit looks very similar to the UK deficit, and similar patterns can be found across the developed world, Northern Europe excepted.

Government Deficits

When asked about the deficit, President Ronald Reagan famously quipped that, “the deficit is big enough to take care of itself.” Yet the 1980s never saw deficits beyond 5% and today, we have 6.3% during a period of economic expansion. Are we not supposed to fix the roof when the sun is shining?

After the First World War, the national debt had increased from £650 million in 1914 to £7.4 billion by 1919. The Prime Minister, David Lloyd George (a liberal), appointed Sir Eric Geddes with the task of balancing the books and reducing public debt. His report became to be known as the Geddes Axe, and it slashed UK public expenditure with brutal cuts, particularly targeted at the armed forces. With Hitler on the rise, these were short-lived, but Geddes was successful in getting public finances back under control and restoring a sense of stability.

The biggest surprise since Trump won the US election, is an outbreak of fiscal prudence. The new Department of Government Efficiency, headed by entrepreneurs Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy, is a potential gamechanger. Along with Argentina’s President Milei, they are the Geddes Axe of the 21^st century. Their task is to roll back the state and balance the budget. If you manage to do that, the debt to GDP ratio will naturally fall over time. Thatcher’s household economics is back.

US federal tax revenues last year were $4.47 trillion, with spending of $6.16 trillion. It is a huge gap but Musk and Ramaswamy have stated they can save $2 trillion. Like Geddes, they are businesspeople, rather than civil servants, and are likely to find savings wherever they look.

But $2 trillion of savings is a tall order, and Musk exaggerates, but this movement goes beyond him. Scott Bessent, a successful hedge fund manager has been appointed Secretary to the Treasury. He was a student of George Soros, and colleague of Stanley Druckenmiller. In my opinion, he’s on the financial A list.

In the Money Maze Podcast recorded last November, Bessent quoted French painter and sculptor, Marcel Duchamp, who said, “If there’s no solution, there’s no problem.”

Bessent spoke of the incredible deficits and debt, and that we have to acknowledge the debt problem in the US and globally. He clearly stated how he wants to be a “part of the solution in terms of figuring out what is a fair and equitable way to get to the other side of this.”

Jens Nordvig from Exante Data, who worked with Bessent, described him as having intellectual curiosity and a deep historical perspective that will allow him to operate in a highly uncertain new regime, and serve as a strong independent analytical voice at a time of mounting economic challenges for the US and the global economy.

He also wrote that when Donald Trump was elected the first time in 2016, markets looked ahead to a regime of lower taxes and expansive fiscal policy. We got a growth boost from both lower taxes and larger government expenditure, especially in 2018, but 2024 is different from 2016. The Federal debt level has grown from 105% of GDP to 123% of GDP. And the fiscal deficit has doubled, from 3.1% in 2016, to more than 6% in 2024. Hence, it will be hard to pursue expansive fiscal policies in the same way as in the first Trump administration.

Another comment from Manish Singh, CIO at Crossbridge Capital, said Bessent will adopt a 3-3-3 policy by:

- reducing the budget deficit to 3% of GDP by 2028,
- boosting GDP growth to 3% through deregulation, and
- increasing daily oil production by 3 million barrels.

It’s not just Musk and Ramaswamy, but Bessent too. We are heading for an era of balanced budgets, as where the US goes, the world will have to follow. This is austerity, of Geddes magnitude, and I cannot see how it will be inflationary. It is not an environment we are used to but will surely be positive for the bond market. Maybe Trump wants his legacy to be the bond market guy rather than the stockmarket guy. It makes sense because Bessent will surely be advising him that the equity boom cannot last forever.